What does “usually” actually mean?

Dr. Petra Kauch

How does this wording affect the approval of genetic engineering facilities?

The Genetic Engineering Act (GenTG) also frequently uses vague terms such as "as a rule." For example, for a laboratory area with security level 3, a lock must "as a rule" be installed for entry and exit. Likewise, a hand basin with elbow, foot, or sensor-operated access must "as a rule" be installed in the lock. The text of the law itself already states that a lock may be dispensed with in justified individual cases. "As a rule" means that such a rule can be deviated from in exceptional cases. However, anyone requesting such an exception faces a greater argumentative burden. They must explain why the safety requirements can be met differently in the individual case. In the case of the lock mentioned above, for example, such a lock can be dispensed with if donor and recipient organisms belonging to risk group 3* are being handled. In these cases, airborne transmission does not occur, so certain safety measures, such as the lock, may be dispensed with. Since this is a case-by-case decision, the licensing authority must agree to the deviation from the standard case.

Back to blog

More articles in the AGCT Genetic Engineering report